The jet engine technology transfer from the United States to India, particularly concerning the General Electric (GE) F414 engine for India’s Light Combat Aircraft (LCA) Tejas Mk2 and other platforms, has seen significant developments but faces ongoing challenges.
Key Developments:
- Agreement and Technology Transfer Scope:
- In June 2023, GE Aerospace signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with Hindustan Aeronautics Limited (HAL) to co-produce F414 engines in India, with an unprecedented 80% technology transfer by value. This includes critical technologies such as:
- Special coatings for erosion and corrosion.
- Machining and coating of single-crystal turbine blades.
- Laser drilling for combustors.
- Complete technology transfer for blisk machining and powder metallurgy discs.
The deal, valued at approximately $1 billion, aims to produce 99 F414-INS6 engines for the LCA Tejas Mk2, with potential applications for twin-engine deck-based fighters and the first two squadrons of the Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft (AMCA).The agreement marks a significant shift from earlier negotiations in 2012, which offered only 58% technology transfer.
- Congressional Approval:
- In August 2023, the U.S. Congress cleared the deal with no objections, allowing GE to proceed with technology transfer, manufacturing, and licensing arrangements. This approval followed notifications to the House and Senate foreign relations committees on July 28, 2023.
Production Timeline:
- The first F414 engine is expected to roll out in India three years after the contract is finalized, with HAL establishing a production facility in Bengaluru. The facility is planned to be operational within two years of the contract signing.
- The deal aims to increase the indigenous content of the LCA Mk2 to around 75%, compared to 55–60% for the LCA Mk1A.
Strategic Significance:
- The deal is seen as a landmark in U.S.-India defense cooperation, reflecting trust in India’s intellectual property rights regime and its reliability as a partner. It aligns with India’s “Make in India” initiative and reduces dependence on foreign suppliers.
The U.S. views this as a strategic move to strengthen India as a counterbalance to China, with the deal described as a “trailblazing initiative” by both nations.
Current Challenges:
- Cost and Technical Issues:
- As of December 2024, the deal has encountered issues, with costs potentially exceeding the initial $1 billion estimate due to technical discussions with HAL. This mirrors challenges faced in other high-profile defense deals like Rafale and Scorpene, where domestic manufacturing costs escalated.
The Indian Ministry of Defence is in the final stages of approving the manufacturing license agreement, but additional approvals are needed due to cost overruns.
Critical Technology Restrictions:
- While 80% technology transfer is significant, certain critical technologies, such as the single-crystal blade casting process and the software for the Full Authority Digital Engine Control (FADEC) system, are retained by GE to safeguard intellectual property. This limits India’s ability to fully indigenize jet engine production.
- The U.S. has historically been cautious about sharing jet engine technology, even with close allies, due to risks of reverse-engineering or technology leakage.
Geopolitical and Policy Concerns:
- The incoming Trump administration (as of January 2025) may introduce delays or restrictions due to concerns over technology transfers, especially given India’s continued energy purchases from Russia and its neutral stance on the Russia-Ukraine conflict.
U.S. export control laws, such as the Arms Export Control Act (AECA) and International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR), impose stringent restrictions, which could complicate or delay the transfer process.
- Supply Chain Delays:
- Delays in the supply of GE F404 engines (used for LCA Tejas Mk1A) due to supply chain issues have already impacted production schedules. Similar risks could affect the F414 deal, potentially delaying the delivery of LCA Mk2 and AMCA variants.
Broader Context:
- India’s Indigenous Efforts: India’s Kaveri engine program, aimed at developing an indigenous jet engine, has faced setbacks since 1989, failing to meet the technical requirements for fighter aircraft. The F414 deal is a critical stopgap to bridge this gap while India continues to explore collaborations with other global manufacturers like Safran (France) and Rolls-Royce (UK) for the AMCA program.
- Alternative Partnerships: India is in talks with Safran and Rolls-Royce for technology transfers to power the AMCA, indicating a multi-pronged approach to reduce reliance on a single supplier.
- Strategic Autonomy: Despite the deal’s significance, some argue that India should invest in fully indigenous jet engine development to achieve strategic autonomy, as complete technology transfer remains elusive.
Current Status (May 2025):
The deal is in the final stages of negotiation, with technical and commercial terms being finalized. The Indian government is reviewing GE’s techno-commercial bids, and the manufacturing license agreement awaits final approval from the Defence Acquisition Council. However, cost overruns and concerns about critical technology restrictions persist, and the Trump administration’s policies could introduce further uncertainties. Production is expected to commence within two to three years of contract signing, assuming no major delays.
www.bbc.com
