Women in Armed Forces

[maximus777]

Women in combat roles is a big mistake, particularly against the desert cult enemies. I fear we will regret this in a future war.


View: https://x.com/ShivAroor/status/1926185220916584781?t=yuFu4Bc_DIkfgRRAmEDxOg&s=19

I hear that comic book and popat followers dont get jannat if knocked off by women. So I have no issues with women in defensive roles like air defence or drone pilots. Offensive physical combat is simply not for women unless we are pushed to the wall having lost a significant population of men. Cant imagine them scaling icy peaks or clearing bunkers in hand to hand combat like in Kargil. Can't risk them as pilots either since their capture can complicate matters for the military and the govt narrative. No disrespect but that's simply the reality.

 

[KiloLimaZulu]

Women in combat roles is a big mistake, particularly against the desert cult enemies. I fear we will regret this in a future war.


View: https://x.com/ShivAroor/status/1926185220916584781?t=yuFu4Bc_DIkfgRRAmEDxOg&s=19

Women should not be in the military. We are literally paying for lower quality soldiers. It also provides a huge PR boost for the enemy. Imagine the humiliation if the news of female piolet getting captured was true.

 

[karn]

Come on, it's a well-known fact that girls do better than boys in academics. There is said to be at least a one-year brain development gap between the genders. Even in India, the pass percentage and average scores of girls in board exams are higher than those of boys.

Yeah ruttofying shit in school is a peak indicator of intelligence .. yet every high tech org is a sausage fest with the female dominated departments being HR.

 

[darkflame]

Yeah ruttofying shit in school is peak indicator of intelligence .. yet every high tech org is a sausage fest

dismissing academic success as 'ruttofying' is just lazy thinking. Also, the fact that many high-tech orgs are male-dominated isn’t proof of superiority — it’s the result of long-standing gender biases, unequal opportunities, and toxic workplace cultures that push women out.

 

[KiloLimaZulu]

If we caught a female or they . So bloody what?

bloody A lot. Its humiliating. More than a man getting caught.

It should be based on merit who ever is better come and prove. Take the job.

Except that's not how it works because women cant pass the military standards so they watered it down. Literally paying the same money for lower quality soldiers.

 

[redpanda]

Can you guys take this discussion to Chit Chat? This is not the place to start this fruitless discussion. Because some people will never bother looking at biological & psychological data. And will bring results from different cases into a context where those doesn't hold much value to prove their point. Unnecessarily dragging the discussion further and further.

 

[karn]

dismissing academic success as 'ruttofying' is just lazy thinking. Also, the fact that many high-tech orgs are male-dominated isn’t proof of superiority — it’s the result of long-standing gender biases, unequal opportunities, and toxic workplace cultures that push women out.

There are literal policies to have more female representation in orgs and all it results in is lower performance. The amount of handholding and intentional bias to have unqualified women attain their positions is comical.

 

[WARREN SS]

"discipline, leadership, and resilience" non of which women excel in. On average men perform better under stress. Women make most of their decisions based on emotions.

Actually its reverse
Women are purely logical
Better Multi taskers
Better at handling emotions

Men on the other hand Supress Emotions And Eventually Die With cardiovascular diseases

Compare Life expentancy you Will get it.

But,

Combant Is Pure Physical Phenomenon Need Peak human conditions

Pitting A Female Unit Against A Male Unit Is Operationally Illogical In Combat operations

 

[Ajatshatru]

Why not ? Kya ho jayega ?

They will humiliate? If they humiliate with chai chai every friggin day is it any less ?

U say go by who ever qualify to be a better pilot .

Kya aadmi ki nanga karega to kam beizzati hogi ? Kya aafat hi jayegi?

Sab bakwas hai . It’s a moral conduct if they follow good or else we face it. If a woman goes to forces she knows what she is doing.

I am a Mongolian nationalist and an alpha male. Mongolian women have participated in combat for thousands of years, but I still don’t think women should be in combat—definitely not against a country like Pakistan.
Older members of this forum know like @haldilal know me

 

[karn]

The thing is indian men are weak they even lose to their own women in fights

View: https://www.reddit.com/r/TotalKalesh/comments/1bgsc5w/kalesh_bw_a_guy_and_orchestra_girl_over_that_guy/

Ah yes this is an absolutely conclusive indictment of all indian males. Please if you are a 50 kg chapri that gets pwned by females don't take it out on the rest of us .

 

[Ajatshatru]

High rollers play for high stakes — the price of every misadventure will be steep. This operation has made it unmistakably clear: every misstep will carry a very high cost. That’s the critical difference this time around.
The intent is clear: mess with the bull, you get the horns. The response will no longer stop at the proxies. from now, the masters behind them will be held accountable.

Kudos to the salt of the earth — the brave and steadfast entrusted with safeguarding the motherland. Their vigilance and sacrifice are the silent strength behind every line held and every threat answered.

India is increasingly adopting a Mongolian approach. I’m impressed with Narendra Modi’s clarity—he thinks and acts like a Mongolian.

 

[Simon Riley]

NOT THE RELEVANT THREAD FOR DISCUSSION OF WOMEN IN COMBAT, WE HAVE A SEPARATE THREAD FOR IT

 

[redpanda]

I am a Mongolian nationalist and an alpha male. Mongolian women have participated in combat for thousands of years, but I still don’t think women should be in combat—definitely not against a country like Pakistan.
Older members of this forum know like @haldilal know me

DrWho guy is just a troll. He is gaslighting to drag this discussion into a mud slinging competition. I have observed him making such troll like comments here for sometime. I would advise you to not entertain him further.

 

[KiloLimaZulu]

Actually its reverse
Women are purely logical
Better Multi taskers
Better at handling emotions

Men on the other hand Supress Emotions And Eventually Die With cardiovascular diseases

Compare Life expentancy you Will get it.

But,

Combant Is Pure Physical Phenomenon Need Peak human conditions

Pitting A Female Unit Against A Male Unit Is Operationally Illogical In Combat operations

Its actually not.
women are the exact opposite of logical. Their hormones fluctuate more than the men. Men evolved to be more logical because it ensured the survival of the species. Hunting and building need more logical minds. Women evolved to be more emotional because nurturing and caring for children require more emotional minds.

lol, have you ever lived with a women? women are the worst at handling emotions.

Men are taught to control their emotion because an emotional man is a uncontrollable and dangerous man. That's not good for society. Prisons are filled with emotional men.

Life expectancy has nothing to do with any of this.

Modern combat Is NOT pure physical phenomenon

"Peak human condition" in combat is to 'perform under extreme duress' which men are better suited for.

 

[sameer]

Never thought this thread would eventually delve into a shouting match between self proclaimed "mongolian nationalists" and "ultra trad feminists"

 

[KumaoniReborn]

Indian man in war is a big mistake specially malnutrition hit people. We have females winning more medals in sports specially combat. While wussy men are worthless. I fear we had a regretted this for past 4000 years when we have been invaded by every Ara garrra nathu khera.

Women of our nation are actually better than men . They are pride of nation when men like you are jugaad of nation.
Ask any father of a daughter he will tell you how his daughters are better than the

Kya aag lag jayegi ? Kaun si aafat a jayegi?

If we caught a female or they . So bloody what?

It should be based on merit who ever is better come and prove. Take the job.

A pilot or a soldier or sniper .who ever if they can beat men why not.

@moderators Please ban this clown. Adding nothing but misandrist bullshit to the conversations

 

[redpanda]

@ezsasa @Vinash @haldilal Please lock this thread. And do something to stop this ridiculous discussion. Also please take action against this guy @Drwho, he literally called all indian man napunsak, malnourished and what not. I don't know if he is truly delusional or acting like one.

 

[Simon Riley]

@ezsasa @Vinash @haldilal Please lock this thread. And do something to stop this ridiculous discussion. Also please take action against this guy @Drwho, he literally called all indian man napunsak, malnourished and what not. I don't know if he is truly delusional or acting like one.

He is a mard e momin from porki land.mard e momins have constantly lost against hindoo wrestlers and in any strength based sport btw. @Drwho porki subhuman stick to grappling with goats. Forget athletes every time Indian soldiers have faced your army in hand to hand combat they whacked the absolute shit out of you. Go ,wank off to laal topi and sleep.

 

[JConline]

This should be a comprehensive rebuttal to whoever is claiming that women can outmatch men, SPECIFICALLY in combat. Wild that we're still having to debate this in the 21st century with the amount of data we have.

https://www.marinecorpstimes.com/news/your-marine-corps/2015/09/10/mixed-gender-teams-come-up-short-in-marines-infantry-experiment/

As for Indian man vs woman, please refer to this article:

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/half-of-all-adults-in-india-unfit-women-most-physically-inactive-study-5973649#:~:text=Far more women in India,those in men, it said.

India doesn't have women in combat roles, so we don't have data like the Americans do. But if more women are physically inactive than men in India, it should tell you quite conclusively how the average Indian woman will fare against an Indian man in a physical contest.

For the people who're gonna come at me with anecdotal evidence like Ronda Rousey vs Peter Dinklage type shit, please take some time and go through the following document. Maybe educate yourself about how women can actually be a force multiplier, rather than trying to peddle your leftist propaganda.

https://press.armywarcollege.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2894&context=parameters

And to everyone who's citing examples of their mother, wife, partner, or any other female family member, please understand that while the exceptionally strong women of your family have my respect, they unfortunately do not have much influence on the median. Please be rational in your arguments, however emotionally moving your opponents' arguments might be.

 

[WARREN SS]

Its actually not.
women are the exact opposite of logical. Their hormones fluctuate more than the men. Men evolved to be more logical because it ensured the survival of the species. Hunting and building need more logical minds. Women evolved to be more emotional because nurturing and caring for children require more emotional minds.

lol, have you ever lived with a women? women are the worst at handling emotions.

Men are taught to control their emotion because an emotional man is a uncontrollable and dangerous man. That's not good for society. Prisons are filled with emotional men.

Life expectancy has nothing to do with any of this.

Modern combat Is NOT pure physical phenomenon

"Peak human condition" in combat is to 'perform under extreme duress' which men are better suited for.

Have ever u lived with women ???

married for 12 years with 3 Kids.

All your assumptions have no backing from
Scientific and clinical studies

Most of my facts are

Based on Empirical Physiological studies
Of both species

Now you saying women are not logical creatures

But all most all IQ clinical studies
planet varies
Men and women. Equals in terms of
Intelligence.

And When it comes to emotional intelligence
Women slightly elevated

But Men overcompensate it with superior physically genetics


I can debate it with you on this topic longer

But it has nothing to do with purpose of this thread

All ready given by opinion on
Women in front line infantry combat role.