Indo US Relations

[Hari Sud]

There is no going back home, nor has canada's thirst for immigrants abated long term- yes, it does require some cooling to let the housing market catch up, as the biggest source of underlying canadian inflationary metrics is independent of trumpwa or murrica and has been onging for 20 years in major canadian cities: severe housing shortage, leading to severe house cost inflation.

However, at the same time, Canadian economy is resource extractive and transportationally expansive,meaning, Canada still needs shit tons of people to keep its resource extractive+transportational economy going. This is also evident in every single economic predictor Carney himself has put out in his career and Carley is your RBI head turned into PM guy,so he is an alltogether different beast to deal with.

What we should expect, regardless of who wins in the elections, is a pre-covid level drop in immigration numbers and not post covid level massive spike - many of whom are actually also ukrainian refugees and certain sections in Canada are trying to scapegoat Indians inorder to shelter the Ukronazis so kindly be aware of that angle and not harm the pro-immigrant fabric of canada.

To think that 500,000 immigrants who arrived under the pretext of student can be absorbed and Canada can redevelop its resource sector is full hardy. Trump has taken extreme step of ejecting unwanted people. The same is possible in Canada. Truthfully, these guys arrived on student visa; as soon as that visa expires, they become illegals. That means no benefits, no charity and no welcome.

 

[GaudaNaresh]

To think that 500,000 immigrants who arrived under the pretext of student can be absorbed and Canada can redevelop its resource sector is full hardy. Trump has taken extreme step of ejecting unwanted people. The same is possible in Canada. Truthfully, these guys arrived on student visa; as soon as that visa expires, they become illegals. That means no benefits, no charity and no welcome.

It isnt foolhardy at all, given that Canada has absorbed approx 250,000 people per annum into the country at the very minimum for well over 20 years and counting.
Canada definitely can re-develop its resource sector and the answer everyone is forgetting here, in josh and jalwaa, is not we re-orient towards Europe economically but towards CHEEN, who still has hunger for resources and we are the second biggest mall on the planet after Russia as far as raw resources goes.

So to think Canada wont restart its ace-in the hole when under pressure from the US is a very unlikely and foolhardy thing to expect from the Canadian govt, especially if PP wins.

Its irrelevant whether you think of them as illegals and want them gone, you can get rid of those 500K itself, but another 150K will show up legally and the immigration train continues as far as canada is concerned. THAT, is reality.
All Canada is going to do,is reduce immigration numbers for half a decade and let the housing market catch up.
We still need a LOT more people here to function properly and not pay absurd costs and surchages just to keep the country running.

 

[Hari Sud]

It isnt foolhardy at all, given that Canada has absorbed approx 250,000 people per annum into the country at the very minimum for well over 20 years and counting.
Canada definitely can re-develop its resource sector and the answer everyone is forgetting here, in josh and jalwaa, is not we re-orient towards Europe economically but towards CHEEN, who still has hunger for resources and we are the second biggest mall on the planet after Russia as far as raw resources goes.

So to think Canada wont restart its ace-in the hole when under pressure from the US is a very unlikely and foolhardy thing to expect from the Canadian govt, especially if PP wins.

Its irrelevant whether you think of them as illegals and want them gone, you can get rid of those 500K itself, but another 150K will show up legally and the immigration train continues as far as canada is concerned. THAT, is reality.
All Canada is going to do,is reduce immigration numbers for half a decade and let the housing market catch up.
We still need a LOT more people here to function properly and not pay absurd costs and surchages just to keep the country running.

Not true whatever you say above. I live in Canada. I see qualified boys and girls doing minimal jobs at Tim Horton and Indian restaurants, or packers or unloaded at department stores. They do not want to do these jobs, but forced to as otherwise no money to pay other necessities of life. I pity them… They were told a lie about high rate of money coming into their pockets after reaching Canada. No it is not coming. They cannot wait for ever that things will get better. The current setup is such that except 1% of total who may get lucky; others will have continue on those minimal jobs and loose all skills they probably acquired after paying Rupees 20/- Lakh to an agent.

 

[GaudaNaresh]

Not true whatever you say above. I live in Canada. I see qualified boys and girls doing minimal jobs at Tim Horton and Indian restaurants, or packers or unloaded at department stores. They do not want to do these jobs, but forced to as otherwise no money to pay other necessities of life. I pity them… They were told a lie about high rate of money coming into their pockets after reaching Canada. No it is not coming. They cannot wait for ever that things will get better. The current setup is such that except 1% of total who may get lucky; others will have continue on those minimal jobs and loose all skills they probably acquired after paying Rupees 20/- Lakh to an agent.

I have been living in canada since last millenium. Immigrants doing menial jobs goes back to the 90s.
You sound very new here.

 

[Prasad]

Canada probably has re-orient its commercial relation with Europe.

There is a new prime minister in Canada. He is unlikely to follow Trudeau’s policy. He is unlikely to get scared by Trump as Trudeau was that after a single and first meeting with Trump at his Golf Ranch, he resigned and then decided to act tough.

New PM Carney will direct his energies in a short time he is left for the elections will open up discussions with Europe to strengthen ties with them. Europe is also under same pressure as Canada is, hence makes sense to strengthen commercial relationship with each other.

It will take 5 years of effort to disengage from America and who so ever becomes the PM of Canada has a major task cut out for them.

In the mean time; Canada would not need so any immigrants who have arrived from Asia under the pretext of studies. They have to be sent back. The Canadian economy already under pressure from Trump has to reorient itself. To do that, Canada will need money and they have to save every penny and not spend on housing, other benefits on immigrants who do not belong here anyway. Trudeau’s invited immigrants have to be clearly told to go back home now.

For Canada, EU will not fill what it lost with USA in terms of market.

There are very few markets for Canada to fill in USA void.

If only Canada did not fk up their relations with India..