AMCA - Advanced Medium Combat Aircraft

[liberalredditor]

Galat jagah bakchodi mat karo bhai
Dont get into X or reddit fight between drdo and isro
Both groups provide retarded arguments
Those guys only read recent updates and make conclusion
They will never understand how much both the institutions are interconnected and manpower or scientists work

Even take a simple example of APJ Kalam and read in depth about his work you will get how stupid it is to compare both

you all are taking it in a wrong way, i am not making thought process with latest update

i meant to say that if isro's project starts at the target that lets get a rover on moon, it ends there, project over, and most of it is taught in colleges or training period
bits pilani ke kisi bhi 3rd year student se puchho jo ps1 ke liye wahan gaya hai, including sensors lab or engines lab or flight path directory lab, they are completely incompetetnt and political

but if drdo has a project, they have to consider 1000s of situations of their use cases, they cannot manage to go like ok 900 situation are good to go, these 100 are low probability we can ignore, no it doesnt happen

what i wanted to compare was, work culture and attitude towards work or a project of importance
isro people are always slacking on projects even though project definition says that project isnt complex, major research is not involved, still they delay as much as possible, pure sarkari attitude
and those in drdo, it has reduced, the sarkari attitude has gone down, the people there are passionate, working on projects even after time to meet timelines and project schedule, but they get delayed mainly due to babu level procurements or testing delays

i again say, i dont have intentions to compare, but it is frustration due to overcelebrating isro's achievements while neglecting all its issues

 

[Gyyaan]

Two questions I have, if I may, Can it fit Astra Mk3 and How many?

I think we can hold Astra Mk3 inside IWb.
Length of Mk3 is same as mk2.
The width for booster section is 200mm.
Likely 4 of these could be carried in IWB

 

[jaijaganath]

you all are taking it in a wrong way, i am not making thought process with latest update

i meant to say that if isro's project starts at the target that lets get a rover on moon, it ends there, project over, and most of it is taught in colleges or training period
bits pilani ke kisi bhi 3rd year student se puchho jo ps1 ke liye wahan gaya hai, including sensors lab or engines lab or flight path directory lab, they are completely incompetetnt and political

but if drdo has a project, they have to consider 1000s of situations of their use cases, they cannot manage to go like ok 900 situation are good to go, these 100 are low probability we can ignore, no it doesnt happen

what i wanted to compare was, work culture and attitude towards work or a project of importance
isro people are always slacking on projects even though project definition says that project isnt complex, major research is not involved, still they delay as much as possible, pure sarkari attitude
and those in drdo, it has reduced, the sarkari attitude has gone down, the people there are passionate, working on projects even after time to meet timelines and project schedule, but they get delayed mainly due to babu level procurements or testing delays

i again say, i dont have intentions to compare, but it is frustration due to overcelebrating isro's achievements while neglecting all its issues

Atleast on this forum no one over celebrate isro
U have already seen criticism in recent times regarding pslv failure
They both have complexities but different objectives
Yes defence related products have moving parts, it has to be used multiple times so it's must be easily serviceable maintainance should be easy and low operation cost
These problems are not faced by isro but they have their own set of problems these guys have to make robust payloads to last years complexity of propulsion is huge despite multiple successful missions
Every rocket u see have to be changed wrt to payload
It's not plug and play
Coming to personal opinions we can't argue nor comment nor generalize things on basis of it
I don't have luxury of speaking to bits pilani interns but what I have heard is exactly opposite but again I can't make conclusion out of it
So if u want to generalize then fine I wouldn't comment

 

[Spitfire IX]

Any expressions of interest in building AMCA through a company 50% controlled by HAL, 12.5% each by 4 other companies? I believe the deadline to express interest was 7th May.