Indian Special Forces

The only Indian SF units I can think of who can possibly carry out a counter terrorist operation like this are MARCOS (VBSS/CQB) and NSG (SAG).

Para SF is not designed for these kinds of operations (assymetric) which is why they were not even considered during 26/11.

Para SF is more of US Army Ranger/ Green Beret specialist for conventional warfare.

GARUDS don't have a lot of operational experience.

Any local police/SWAT/QRT is best used for screening and chasing local leads.
In Mumbai instantly available capable force is marcos which was stationed there so they called for situation control then nsg hold the ground , many nsg guys got kia , 1 marco got severely injured
Similar situation happened in pampore then para sf was called and all hostages were rescued , 3 braveheart got kia also
It was just the matter of time and availability
 
Unpopular opinion: the 25,000 SF allowance should be ammended in a way that you can only spend it on PPE and get refunds when you show proof of purchase.
It’s a typical dehat mindset seen in many Indians—what’s the point of saving money if you never use it? And if something happens to you, what will your family do with that unspent money? It’s disheartening that we have to push people to prioritize essential purchases, especially when such items should be their first priority using special allowances.

Yet, for many Indians—regardless of their profession—showing off iPhones and four-wheelers seems to take front seat.
 



Given the terrain and this train being held up in a remote region, it'd be extremely hard for Indian SF to handle such an op. NSG took days to wrap up the ops in Mumbai or Pathankot and in this case, with suicide bombers holding hostage a large number of passengers where the potential for fatalities is significantly high - GoI would probably spend days in negotiations just trying to wear em' out

Also, Marcos might not want to take up this op since this isn't their turf but might act as a support group if requested, no point considering Garuds since they're more like glorified air base security. It should be NSG only or a combo of NSG (SAG) and Para SF (OG units) with support from Marcos
 

Latest Replies

Featured Content

Trending Threads

Back
Top