- Joined
- Sep 5, 2024
- Messages
- 810
- Likes
- 3,311
Ran another IN vs PN & PAF Scenario.
- PN launched all their anti-ship missiles when they detected IN, IA & IAF launch. PAF too launched a significant salvo initially but were also able to rearm and launch more times.
- Pakistan had access to all Chinese satellites
- Indian initial salvo was more sophisticated this time:
IN fired at least 4 brahmos at each PN ship
IAF launched brahmos & Scalp EG at Karachi Port, Karachi & Bholari airbase
IA launched land attack brahmos at Karachi Port & refinery
- This main engagement was over in 3 rounds. So no IAF Jaguars were able to launch Harpoon as they had to takeoff from Jamnagar and reach their launch points and by that time all PN ships were sunk.
- IN Composition
SAG 1 - 1x P15A [Kolkata destroyer], 2x Talwar Class Frigate [Batch 2], 1x P17 [Shivalik Class], 1x P15 [Delhi Class], 1x Type209 [Shishumar]
SAG 2 - 1x P15A [Kolkata], 1x P15 [Delhi], 1x P28 [Kamorta], 2x Talwar [Batch 2]
CBG - 2x P15B [Vishakhapatnam destroyer], 2x P17A [Nilgiri Frigate], 1x P17 [Shivalik Class], 1x P28 [Kamorta], 1x Vikrant, 1x Scorpene [Kalvari]
Independent units - 1x Scorpene, 3x Kilo
- 3x Agosta 90B submarines were provided. One was located in middle of CBG and SAG2. Another one in front of CBG and third one in front of SAG1. Since the engagement was over in 3 rounds there was no detection or counter detections. Land attack Klub are not available with Kilo submarine in CMO.
- There were AA/BVR engagements over Gujarat border and no shootdowns on either side.
Conclusions:
- In PN/PAF first counter response, YJ12A sunk 1x Talwar frigate from SAG1. In my observation Barak8 is critical, there was only 1 Barak8/MRSAM equipped ship in this SAG. It was located a bit too far towards the right of this sunk ship in the group and could not intercept a couple of YJ12As that struck. I think each SAG requires at least 2 MRSAM equipped ships. More MRSAM ships that can be added to CBG and SAG the better it is.
- PAF losses were on ground when Pasni and Karachi airbases were hit. Same with P3 at Karachi.
- Some of the Harbah anti-ship missiles had to be engaged with CIWS [AK630]
- Almost 70-75% of Pakistan missile attacks were focused on CBG. Rest were on SAG1 with SAG2 only facing minimal threat as it was located opposite Gwadar [far from Karachi]. In this scenario only F16s were based in Pasni.
- SAG-1 ran out of Barak-8s and after a ship was sunk I launched all remaining brahmos and withdrew this group. There was 1 attack on the retreating group with 2x CM400 but they were intercepted with Shtil SAM. CBG also expended more than 80% of Barak-8s.
- 16x Babur were fired on Jamnagar refinery. Refinery escaped unharmed with point defense provided by Spyder and L-70 AD guns which took down all missiles.
- Karachi port/base destroyed with brahmos
- Karachi refinery destroyed with brahmos
- Ormara naval base/pier damaged with Rampage hits
- PN Surface fleet all sunk with brahmos
- Karachi JY-27 radar destroyed with brahmos
- Karachi HQ-9B destroyed with brahmos & Rampage
- Karachi airbase damaged with brahmos & Rampage
- Pasni airbase damaged with Rampage
SIDE: INDIA
===========================================================
LOSSES:
-------------------------------
1x F 45 Teg [Talwar Class, Batch 2, Pr.1135.6]
EXPENDITURES:
------------------
1x 100mm/59 A-190 Frag
60x 40mm/70 Single Bofors Burst [4 rnds, Flycatcher Mk1 FCR]
12x 76mm/62 Compact HE Burst [4 rnds]
12x 76mm/62 Super Rapido HE Burst [2 rnds]
3x AA-11 Archer [R-73]
33x AA-12 Adder A [R-77, RVV-AE]
2x AK-630 30mm/65 Gatling Burst [400 rnds]
9x AK-630M 30mm/65 Gatling Burst [400 rnds]
8x AS-20 Kayak [Kh-35U Star]
11x Astra Mk1
1x Barak 1
186x Barak 8
4x Kavach Chaff [Long Range]
4x Kavach Chaff [Medium Range]
4x Kavach Chaff [Short Range]
4x KT-216 Chaff
60x PJ-10 BrahMos
20x PJ-10 BrahMos
14x PJ-10 BrahMos Blk II [Land-Attack]
8x PJ-10 BrahMos-A
14x Python 5 [SPYDER-MR]
22x Rampage
48x SA-21a Growler [48N6DM]
47x SA-N-12 Grizzly [9M317]
6x SA-N-7 Gadfly [9M38]
4x SCALP EG
8x Super Barricade Chaff
SIDE: PAK
===========================================================
LOSSES:
-------------------------------
2x 30mm China LD-2000 [Type 730]
1x AvGas Tank Farm (40 x 75k Liter Tank)
4x F 251 Zulfiquar [F-22P Class, Mod Type 053H3 Jiangwei II]
1x F 260 Alamgir [Perry Class]
2x F 280 Babur [Ada Class]
1x F-16CJ Blk 52+ Falcon [Peace Drive]
4x FFG 261 Tughril [Type 054A/P Jiangkai II]
6x HQ-9B TEL
2x HQ-9B TEL
2x JF-17C Thunder Blk 3 [FC-1]
2x P-3C Orion Update II
1x Radar (China JY-27A)
3x Sky Sabre [Land Ceptor]
1x Structure (Pier [Large (25.1-45m) x 1])
1x Structure (Pier [Very Large (45.1-200m) x 2])
1x Vehicle (China HT-233)
1x Vehicle (China Type 280)
1x Vehicle (Land Ceptor)
EXPENDITURES:
------------------
21x 30mm China H/PJ-12 [Type 730, 240 rnds]
3x 35mm Twin Oerlikon KDC-02 Burst [20 rnds]
2x 76mm/62 Super Rapido HE Burst [2 rnds]
8x AIM-120C-5 AMRAAM P3I.2
24x CAMM-ER
18x CH-AA-10 Abaddon [PL-15E]
34x CM-400Akg Wrecker [ASM, YJ-12 Derivative]
10x CSS-N-8 Saccade [YJ-83K]
22x Generic Chaff Rocket
2x Generic Chaff Salvo [5x Cartridges]
12x Harbah
16x Hatf 7 [700kg HE Conventional, Babur]
112x HQ-16A [SA-17 Semi-Copy]
10x HQ-7 Crotale [FM-80] Naval
63x HQ-9B
4x Mk214 Sea Gnat Chaff [Seduction]
8x Mk234 Nulka
24x Sky Sabre [Land Ceptor]
32x YJ-12A
- PN launched all their anti-ship missiles when they detected IN, IA & IAF launch. PAF too launched a significant salvo initially but were also able to rearm and launch more times.
- Pakistan had access to all Chinese satellites
- Indian initial salvo was more sophisticated this time:
IN fired at least 4 brahmos at each PN ship
IAF launched brahmos & Scalp EG at Karachi Port, Karachi & Bholari airbase
IA launched land attack brahmos at Karachi Port & refinery
- This main engagement was over in 3 rounds. So no IAF Jaguars were able to launch Harpoon as they had to takeoff from Jamnagar and reach their launch points and by that time all PN ships were sunk.
- IN Composition
SAG 1 - 1x P15A [Kolkata destroyer], 2x Talwar Class Frigate [Batch 2], 1x P17 [Shivalik Class], 1x P15 [Delhi Class], 1x Type209 [Shishumar]
SAG 2 - 1x P15A [Kolkata], 1x P15 [Delhi], 1x P28 [Kamorta], 2x Talwar [Batch 2]
CBG - 2x P15B [Vishakhapatnam destroyer], 2x P17A [Nilgiri Frigate], 1x P17 [Shivalik Class], 1x P28 [Kamorta], 1x Vikrant, 1x Scorpene [Kalvari]
Independent units - 1x Scorpene, 3x Kilo
- 3x Agosta 90B submarines were provided. One was located in middle of CBG and SAG2. Another one in front of CBG and third one in front of SAG1. Since the engagement was over in 3 rounds there was no detection or counter detections. Land attack Klub are not available with Kilo submarine in CMO.
- There were AA/BVR engagements over Gujarat border and no shootdowns on either side.
Conclusions:
- In PN/PAF first counter response, YJ12A sunk 1x Talwar frigate from SAG1. In my observation Barak8 is critical, there was only 1 Barak8/MRSAM equipped ship in this SAG. It was located a bit too far towards the right of this sunk ship in the group and could not intercept a couple of YJ12As that struck. I think each SAG requires at least 2 MRSAM equipped ships. More MRSAM ships that can be added to CBG and SAG the better it is.
- PAF losses were on ground when Pasni and Karachi airbases were hit. Same with P3 at Karachi.
- Some of the Harbah anti-ship missiles had to be engaged with CIWS [AK630]
- Almost 70-75% of Pakistan missile attacks were focused on CBG. Rest were on SAG1 with SAG2 only facing minimal threat as it was located opposite Gwadar [far from Karachi]. In this scenario only F16s were based in Pasni.
- SAG-1 ran out of Barak-8s and after a ship was sunk I launched all remaining brahmos and withdrew this group. There was 1 attack on the retreating group with 2x CM400 but they were intercepted with Shtil SAM. CBG also expended more than 80% of Barak-8s.
- 16x Babur were fired on Jamnagar refinery. Refinery escaped unharmed with point defense provided by Spyder and L-70 AD guns which took down all missiles.
- Karachi port/base destroyed with brahmos
- Karachi refinery destroyed with brahmos
- Ormara naval base/pier damaged with Rampage hits
- PN Surface fleet all sunk with brahmos
- Karachi JY-27 radar destroyed with brahmos
- Karachi HQ-9B destroyed with brahmos & Rampage
- Karachi airbase damaged with brahmos & Rampage
- Pasni airbase damaged with Rampage
SIDE: INDIA
===========================================================
LOSSES:
-------------------------------
1x F 45 Teg [Talwar Class, Batch 2, Pr.1135.6]
EXPENDITURES:
------------------
1x 100mm/59 A-190 Frag
60x 40mm/70 Single Bofors Burst [4 rnds, Flycatcher Mk1 FCR]
12x 76mm/62 Compact HE Burst [4 rnds]
12x 76mm/62 Super Rapido HE Burst [2 rnds]
3x AA-11 Archer [R-73]
33x AA-12 Adder A [R-77, RVV-AE]
2x AK-630 30mm/65 Gatling Burst [400 rnds]
9x AK-630M 30mm/65 Gatling Burst [400 rnds]
8x AS-20 Kayak [Kh-35U Star]
11x Astra Mk1
1x Barak 1
186x Barak 8
4x Kavach Chaff [Long Range]
4x Kavach Chaff [Medium Range]
4x Kavach Chaff [Short Range]
4x KT-216 Chaff
60x PJ-10 BrahMos
20x PJ-10 BrahMos
14x PJ-10 BrahMos Blk II [Land-Attack]
8x PJ-10 BrahMos-A
14x Python 5 [SPYDER-MR]
22x Rampage
48x SA-21a Growler [48N6DM]
47x SA-N-12 Grizzly [9M317]
6x SA-N-7 Gadfly [9M38]
4x SCALP EG
8x Super Barricade Chaff
SIDE: PAK
===========================================================
LOSSES:
-------------------------------
2x 30mm China LD-2000 [Type 730]
1x AvGas Tank Farm (40 x 75k Liter Tank)
4x F 251 Zulfiquar [F-22P Class, Mod Type 053H3 Jiangwei II]
1x F 260 Alamgir [Perry Class]
2x F 280 Babur [Ada Class]
1x F-16CJ Blk 52+ Falcon [Peace Drive]
4x FFG 261 Tughril [Type 054A/P Jiangkai II]
6x HQ-9B TEL
2x HQ-9B TEL
2x JF-17C Thunder Blk 3 [FC-1]
2x P-3C Orion Update II
1x Radar (China JY-27A)
3x Sky Sabre [Land Ceptor]
1x Structure (Pier [Large (25.1-45m) x 1])
1x Structure (Pier [Very Large (45.1-200m) x 2])
1x Vehicle (China HT-233)
1x Vehicle (China Type 280)
1x Vehicle (Land Ceptor)
EXPENDITURES:
------------------
21x 30mm China H/PJ-12 [Type 730, 240 rnds]
3x 35mm Twin Oerlikon KDC-02 Burst [20 rnds]
2x 76mm/62 Super Rapido HE Burst [2 rnds]
8x AIM-120C-5 AMRAAM P3I.2
24x CAMM-ER
18x CH-AA-10 Abaddon [PL-15E]
34x CM-400Akg Wrecker [ASM, YJ-12 Derivative]
10x CSS-N-8 Saccade [YJ-83K]
22x Generic Chaff Rocket
2x Generic Chaff Salvo [5x Cartridges]
12x Harbah
16x Hatf 7 [700kg HE Conventional, Babur]
112x HQ-16A [SA-17 Semi-Copy]
10x HQ-7 Crotale [FM-80] Naval
63x HQ-9B
4x Mk214 Sea Gnat Chaff [Seduction]
8x Mk234 Nulka
24x Sky Sabre [Land Ceptor]
32x YJ-12A
Last edited:
which Russkies help us build. It's frustrating af.
.
