- Joined
- Jul 2, 2024
- Messages
- 102
- Likes
- 185
If It really has 53% indigenous content then it's better to change the mk2 Design and run it on al31 engine science murrican engines are gone now.
Cost, current tooling & manufacturing practices will have to be altered and all aircraft will have to be re-certified which will only add to delays.Why not get the AL-41??
These are not something ARDE is working on, it's rather like an unrelated "descriptive research" we all used to add in our dissertation report to reach the minimum words limit. Remember we're a very budget constrained R&D institution, we take up research only when we're asked by the end users.
But the extra 40 kN wet-thrust from a slightly lighter engine is worth it.Cost, current tooling & manufacturing practices will have to be altered and all aircraft will have to be re-certified which will only add to delays.
Arey delay to pahele hi ho chuka hai, we waited this long, how much worse can another one or two years be??Cost, current tooling & manufacturing practices will have to be altered and all aircraft will have to be re-certified which will only add to delays.
Right that's wat I want to sayIf It really has 53% indigenous content then it's better to change the mk2 Design and run it on al31 engine science murrican engines are gone now.
Extra virgin air force with 12 years of lch testing 15 years of lch testing and even then had to be forced to place ordersChad Indian Navy with 1-2 Year trial and Induction.
Vs
Virgin Indian Army with 10+year trial only for ATAGS.
So what components do we source from Russia still? Since you presented a detailed reply. Can you please list what kind of manufacturing technologies we have already mastered and what need to be mastered to make 1. AL-31F 2. F-414 Class Reliable Engine.After the press release on procurement of 240 AL-31FP at a cost of Rs 26k crores, there has been considerable confusion among defense aficionados regarding the indigenous content.
Well, allow me to clarify your doubts.
Like Su-30MKI licensed production in Nashik, manufacturing of AL-31FP in Koraput consists of 4 phases. In the first phase, engines were manufactured from SKD kits supplied by NPO Saturn, in the next phase there were some percentage of indigenisation but still we were assembling the entire entire from CKD kits. The fourth phase entails manufacturing from raw material stage.
In this phase, all castings,forgings,sheet metal job everything is done by HAL in house from raw materials either sourced from other PSUs/private industry and OEM in Russia.
View attachment 8389
So what is the present indigenisation level of AL-31FP? It's 53 percent. Seems low right. But here's a caveat. This 53 percent is in terms of cost of the engine. In reality, HAL makes 87.7 percent of the assemblies and sub assemblies at Koraput from raw material stage.
Everything you can think of in a gas turbine or jet engine is made here. IGV , LPC aerofoils, discs and stators , HPC bladed,discs and stators, annular combustor , intermediate casing , HPT blades and vanes, LPT blades and vanes, flame holder assembly, and con di axi symmetric nozzle petals,flaps . The tech transfer involved in AL-31FP is much higher than what is envisaged for the much routed GE F414 INS6 Make in India deal.
Retired HAL chief , Mr T Suvarna Raju has gone on record saying that all assemblies and sub assemblies , forgings and castings are made here. He handed over the 50th AL-31FP made from raw material stage to Air Marshal SB Deo.
View attachment 8390
This was in Oct 17.
So people will ask about the significance of 54 percent indigenous content in this present deal. Well, this figure is by cost. When this is implemented, the figure of 87 percent of total components made here by HAL will further increase.
DMRL has an active project to enhance the service life of the entire engine. AL-31FP has a technical life of 2000 hrs. DMRL has already perfected the design and mass manufacture of 3rd gen SC turbine blades. AL-31FP used first gen SC. This can be used along with indigenously developed TVC to increase the performance of AL-31FP but this will require certification from cemilac and an extensive flight test campaign.
Apparantly this is how easy it is to be a defence expert or even worse; a defence and aerospace entrepreneur in India
View: https://x.com/alpha_defense/status/1830947388267036897?s=19
Delulu is indeed the solulu
Guys I know this video is not about INdian defence system. Any idea which missile - the developer is talking about in this video:
View: https://youtu.be/VPSm9gJkPxU?t=508
Guys I know this video is not about INdian defence system. Any idea which missile - the developer is talking about in this video:
View: https://youtu.be/VPSm9gJkPxU?t=508
So what components do we source from Russia still? Since you presented a detailed reply. Can you please list what kind of manufacturing technologies we have already mastered and what need to be mastered to make 1. AL-31F 2. F-414 Class Reliable Engine.