Indian Navy Developments & Discussions

[jaijaganath]

Oooff this one's now going to be scuttled!
View attachment 3892

It seems to be completely destroyed

 

[darkflame]

Oooff this one's now going to be scuttled!
View attachment 3892

lets see what happens, gaye bhains pani mey

 

[jaijaganath]

View: https://twitter.com/BharatShaktiBSI/status/1815397165394452776

 

[Mr.Evil]

How did it get this much damage by just fire?

View: https://x.com/BharatShaktiBSI/status/1815397165394452776

 

[darkflame]

View: https://x.com/alpha_defense/status/1815400028032078316

 

[VictorDelta4]

lets see what happens, gaye bhains pani mey

Atleast if we can get it floating upright, then we have something for a SINKEX!

 

[darkflame]

Atleast if we can get it floating upright, then we have something for a SINKEX!

if navy gets it floating they will probably send it for refits, I think

 

[Fatalis]

How did it get this much damage by just fire?

View: https://x.com/BharatShaktiBSI/status/1815397165394452776

Man, this is so heartbreaking. This puts a lot of question on our safety standards.

 

[Mr.Evil]

Can anyone explain how can a fire on hull sink the ship is that possible?also the safety protocols surely there are way to stop a fire where they are working.

 

[Fatalis]

It's CRN-91. GRSE will be manufacturing CRN-91 for ASW SWC.

But GRSE was developing a 30mm Naval Surface Gun, right?

 

[DumbPilot]

Can anyone explain how can a fire on hull sink the ship is that possible?also the safety protocols surely there are way to stop a fire where they are working.

In Mega-Accident, Warship INS Betwa Flips Over, 2 Sailors Dead

India's prized warship INS Betwa, a guided missile frigate, tipped over and crashed to its side while undocking in Mumbai on Monday, in what the navy described as an "unprecedented and sad" incident. Two sailors have died while 14 others have been rescued with minor injuries.

www.ndtv.com

Apparently INS Betwa(same Brahmaputra class) also flipped over at the graving dock in 2015.

Might be something to look into, although I doubt anything substantial will be correlated as that was a dry dock.

 

[Noob]

@Binayak95 bhaiya anything suspicious or a fire is that lethal for a ship?(I am not very familiar with ships) will a equiry be called?

 

[DumbPilot]

In Mega-Accident, Warship INS Betwa Flips Over, 2 Sailors Dead

India's prized warship INS Betwa, a guided missile frigate, tipped over and crashed to its side while undocking in Mumbai on Monday, in what the navy described as an "unprecedented and sad" incident. Two sailors have died while 14 others have been rescued with minor injuries.

www.ndtv.com

Apparently INS Betwa(same Brahmaputra class) also flipped over at the graving dock in 2015.

Might be something to look into, although I doubt anything substantial will be correlated as that was a dry dock.

Speaking as a google-er, but it might be that the antiroll tanks ruptured due to the fire, and while trying to douse out that fire, they pumped enough water to actually destabilize the ship.

Stability at Shipboard Fires

Land-Based Firefighter talking to a ship’s Master… “Well, the fire went out”…. “Yeah but you sank my ship!”…. “I know that, but the fire did go out!” There have been many tragic stories of fire departments valiantly fighting a fire aboard a large ship for hours, and even days, only to have the...

iffmag.com

 

[Mr.Evil]

@Binayak95 bhaiya we need a navy professional here cause all of this is going from top of my head.

 

[bakofbakchod]

Indian military cant seem to go 1 week without embarrassing itself somehow. Pathetic. Not the first time such an accident happened in drydock. There was a big string of such accidents happening in the previous decade

 

[SKC]

Indian military cant seem to go 1 week without embarrassing itself somehow. Pathetic. Not the first time such an accident happened in drydock. There was a big string of such accidents happening in the previous decade

I don't have any hope with our Indian workforce. There is simply no adherence to Discipline and Protocols anywhere, sab jugaad se chal raha hai!

 

[FalconSlayers]

Already size of military equipment arsenal is small, it is ageing rapidly, no signs of modernisation and expansion and then we have them crashing, sinking and flowing away in rivers regularly on top of terror attacks daily. One must question the competence of the military, this isn't normal.

Indian military cant seem to go 1 week without embarrassing itself somehow. Pathetic. Not the first time such an accident happened in drydock. There was a big string of such accidents happening in the previous decade

 

[125mm_Smoothbore]

Oooff this one's now going to be scuttled!
View attachment 3892

Damn there goes 3-6 years or probably unservisable

 

[darkflame]

In Mega-Accident, Warship INS Betwa Flips Over, 2 Sailors Dead

India's prized warship INS Betwa, a guided missile frigate, tipped over and crashed to its side while undocking in Mumbai on Monday, in what the navy described as an "unprecedented and sad" incident. Two sailors have died while 14 others have been rescued with minor injuries.

www.ndtv.com

Apparently INS Betwa(same Brahmaputra class) also flipped over at the graving dock in 2015.

Might be something to look into, although I doubt anything substantial will be correlated as that was a dry dock.

Damn there goes 3-6 years or probably unservisable

it was going for refit either way,hope she joins service again

 

[125mm_Smoothbore]

@Binayak95 bhaiya we need a navy professional here cause all of this is going from top of my head.

depends on the fire too if they are damn nasty they can take down ships too the ballast problems or hull ruptures