Indian Politics and Democracy

[Prasad]

such a fundamental misreading of India's political history.

you want BJP a political party that got created as a response of congress's emergency, to create conditions for history to repeat itself.

even 90's kids will have understanding of this. are you 2000's born ?

Change rules, curtail state powers and steam roll - random internet guy

BJP loses power, Cong comes to power, uses BJP's curtailing of states powers to bring back 370 and bring in more illegals into India.

The checks, balances and center-state relations are there for a reason.
The framers of our constitution were very smart in framing these rules.

Some of the suggestions online are so bizarre, almost childish - i must have my way by any means.

 

[ezsasa]

Some of the suggestions online are so bizarre, almost childish - i must have my way by any means.

ignorance and arrogance, deadly cocktail.

 

[Spacemarine]

such a fundamental misreading of India's political history.

you want BJP a political party that got created as a response of congress's emergency, to create conditions for history to repeat itself.

even 90's kids will have understanding of this. are you 2000's born ?

Ok so now you are basically trying to attack me instead of answering…

“what if” logic

Okay tell me something what if congoons still do all those things Modi govt is not doing thinking what if congoons do this IF they come into power

 

[Spacemarine]

Change rules, curtail state powers and steam roll - random internet guy

BJP loses power, Cong comes to power, uses BJP's curtailing of states powers to bring back 370 and bring in more illegals into India.

The checks, balances and center-state relations are there for a reason.
The framers of our constitution were very smart in framing these rules.

Some of the suggestions online are so bizarre, almost childish - i must have my way by any means.

Ok not so random guy on internet…

WHAT if congress comes to power and does all these things still

 

[Prasad]

Ok not so random guy on internet…

WHAT if congress comes to power and does all these things still

They can't.
The constitution is absolute on powers of state and center. There are many recommended literature on this. Start with Sarkaria Commission.

States have absolute powers in many matters and center can't even dream of intruding.
That is absolute and final.

 

[Spacemarine]

They can't.
The constitution is absolute on powers of state and center. There are many recommended literature on this. Start with Sarkaria Commission.

States have absolute powers in many matters and center can't even dream of intruding.
That is absolute and final.

It seems congoons already did this plenty of times in history …

from where do you think Article 370 came from?

 

[truthsoldier]

Year 2047 : Sarkar humari hai but system unka hai saar

View: https://x.com/ShefVaidya/status/1857282178972827777?t=ccoGLiptoNe7HK91K4Edqg&s=19

 

[Prasad]

It seems congoons already did this plenty of times in history …

from where do you think Article 370 came from?

Why not go and revisit how 370 was removed.

Even states had to approve it.
meaning, even though the bill passed in LS, it went to states and the state assembly passed the change as well.

 

[Spacemarine]

Why not go and revisit how 370 was removed.

Even states had to approve it.
meaning, even though the bill passed in LS, it went to states and the state assembly passed the change as well.

Check how many times congoons has amended constitution.. check how they even changed the basic nature of constitution by adding socialist and secular words …

Modi should not become impotent now this is very likely his last term.. take hard actions required for making sure Indian national security is strengthened stop thinking about “What if”
Scenarios

 

[Cheepek]

Lehru ji was truly a foreign policy dwarf, high on ideals and low on pragmatism



View: https://x.com/btarunr/status/1857280319394664576?t=29wC1cnXY_RfpQ_Mi8OULQ&s=19

 

[shade2]

After more than decade in power still identify?

I can understand passiveness of Modi on sicks where he thinks better to offer rear to sicks but regarding throwing the bangla muslim filth back to bangladesh what the fuck was these guys doing???

There is a (((due process))) to be followed, I didn't know about this but per ezsasa post below that is the state level process

central gormint does not have jurisdiction at state level, local police have to present the identified people infront of court or tribunal after identification, and during the trial period they have to be put up in state govt camps. after trial if persons are deemed illegal immigrants, they are handed over to BD authorities.

for all this, state govt is a required.

Now after this also, the receiving country that is Kangladesh has to accept the deportation, which they have very rarely even during Sheikh Hasina's tenure.

Aside from this many of your Kanglus have aadhar, voter id and even passport, they tried meanwhile to implement the NRC in Assam and many Hindus didn't have the relevant (((documents))) but Kanglus had the full set as mentioned above.

The solution ofc is extra-legal, where Kanglus on their own go back to where they came from, reverse pole vaulting back into BeeDee

 

[truthsoldier]

There is a (((due process))) to be followed, I didn't know about this but per ezsasa post below that is the state level process



Now after this also, the receiving country that is Kangladesh has to accept the deportation, which they have very rarely even during Sheikh Hasina's tenure.

Aside from this many of your Kanglus have aadhar, voter id and even passport, they tried meanwhile to implement the NRC in Assam and many Hindus didn't have the relevant (((documents))) but Kanglus had the full set as mentioned above.

The solution ofc is extra-legal, where Kanglus on their own go back to where they came from, reverse pole vaulting back into BeeDee

But the deportation data of last 10 years is saying something else. One would expect deportation to increase in BJP rule rather it has fallen, even Congress deported more number of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants

 

[shade2]

But the deportation data of last 10 years is saying something else. One would expect deportation to increase in BJP rule rather it has fallen, even Congress deported more number of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants

btw one question, after deportation who's to say they won't come right back?

 

[crazywithmath]

But the deportation data of last 10 years is saying something else. One would expect deportation to increase in BJP rule rather it has fallen, even Congress deported more number of illegal Bangladeshi immigrants

Much of deportation data is not even public. For determining something as simple as the avg no of illegal immigrants deported between 2014 and 2023, you will need to dig up a LOT.

 

[Screambowl]

BJP loses power, Cong comes to power, uses BJP's curtailing of states powers to bring back 370 and bring in more illegals into India.

Congress will never bring A370 back, for gaining muslim votes they may make promise but we know what happens when congress promises something, congress is master of deception. By the way Congress once had more kattar Hindus than BJP, even now congressis are more kattar in many areas. Remember who was in center when Babri fell?

Every one knows Narsihman rao was actually a pro RSS and Atal Bihari Vajpayee was more liberal and secular.

 

[Prasad]

Congress will never bring A370 back, for gaining muslim votes they may make promise but we know what happens when congress promises something, congress is master of deception. By the way Congress once had more kattar Hindus than BJP, even now congressis are more kattar in many areas. Remember who was in center when Babri fell?

Every one knows Narsihman rao was actually a pro RSS and Atal Bihari Vajpayee was more liberal and secular.

It's an example of what happens if you remove power of states.
To bring 370 back, just passing in LS is not enough.
It should go through states & it will always fail there.

An example to show why states have the powers they have.

 

[Azaad]

.

It's an example of what happens if you remove power of states.
To bring 370 back, just passing in LS is not enough.
It should go through states & it will always fail there.

An example to show why states have the powers they have.

What's restitution or removal of article 370 got to do with other states ? That article was unique to the state of J&K just as there are other such articles concerning a few NE states .

 

[shade2]

'Ajit Pawar was with anti-Hindu ideologies,' says Fadnavis on NCP's opposition to 'Katenge to Batenge'

It will take Ajit Pawar some time to understand public mood, says Fadnavis. Adds that he sees nothing wrong with slogan given by Yogi Adityanath and 'this is the history of this country'.

theprint.in

Ajit Pawar was with anti-Hindu ideologies,’ says Fadnavis on NCP’s opposition to ‘Katenge to Batenge​

Ajit's NCP has been allotted 50 seats for this election

 

[shade2]

Ajit Pawar’s NCP will emerge ‘kingmaker’ in Maharashtra, will join govt ‘on own terms’—Nawab Malik

In conversation with ThePrint, five-time MLA Nawab Malik also talks about his decision to join Ajit Pawar-led NCP and communally charged remarks by leaders of Mahayuti ally BJP.

theprint.in

Confidence of Bhajipao Ally's favorite politcian

 

[Azaad]

Ajit Pawar’s NCP will emerge ‘kingmaker’ in Maharashtra, will join govt ‘on own terms’—Nawab Malik

In conversation with ThePrint, five-time MLA Nawab Malik also talks about his decision to join Ajit Pawar-led NCP and communally charged remarks by leaders of Mahayuti ally BJP.

theprint.in

Confidence of Bhajipao Ally's favorite politcian

Tbh that's what both factions of the NCP are hoping for & if they both get an adequate number of seats it's not inconceivable to think they'd merge & be part of a winning coalition.