Indian Politics and Democracy

Vishnugupt said:
Now I am 100% sure BJP will be out of power in 2029. This is one of biggest masterstroke BJP has played after preserving SC-ST act.

The beneficiary of reservation are Yadav,Jatav and Meena. None of them votes for BJP. Now other SC-ST caste will also not vote for BJP.
Click to expand...
Few quick points :-

Sub classifications can be done by state governments. Central Government is not required to do so from what I understand by the judgement .

Secondly it's a case of once bitten twice shy for the BJP. They've just come out of an election where the opposition somewhat successfully sold the idea that the BJP getting 400 seats involved amending the constitution to do away with reservations altogether thus driving away the SC /ST vote from the BJP.

Thirdly the judgement of the SC involves identifying the creamy layer which short of a caste census can't be undertaken , I imagine.
 
Azaad said:
Few quick points :-

Sub classifications can be done by state governments. Central Government is not required to do so from what I understand by the judgement .

Secondly it's a case of once bitten twice shy for the BJP. They've just come out of an election where the opposition somewhat successfully sold the idea that the BJP getting 400 seats involved amending the constitution to do away with reservations altogether thus driving away the SC /ST vote from the BJP.

Thirdly the judgement of the SC involves identifying the creamy layer which short of a caste census can't be undertaken , I imagine.
Click to expand...

BJP should focus on wining the elections not the hearts of Yadav Jatav and Mulahh. These people know very well BJP is not going to change anything still they prefer lies and propaganda.

Miserable performance of BJP in 2024 election was due to giving free hand to propagandist and sucking up to Yadav, Jatav and Pasmanda.

In return, BJP core voter feels disheartened which results in low Pro-BJP voting and excess anti-BJP voting.

BJP lost an election in MP due to Draconian SC-ST act. None of pro-BJP happy with this act but still BJP sucked for Jatavs.

Now after this master stroke, Valmiki, Dhobi, Kumhar, Teli, Khangar and many more castes will not for BJP.

BJP just committed suicide. Just see in next state election. BJP will lose squarely.
 
Nutcracker said:
Let bottom 90% of SCSTs protest against the status quo if they want creamy layer. Why should BJP burn it's hands. Let it simmer and stay a discussion point till 2027 or 2029.
Click to expand...
You are right,it should be sc st themself who should protest against people who already have their father,grandfather,mother etc sarkari job from reservation getting reservation benifits,
This mentality of Sarkar maibaap is reason “dhindus” are so pathetic and sitting duck.

@ezasa and other knowledgeable members
What would happen if GOI ban all aliens own communication channels ,media, as well as SM including google. What would be consquence from burger land.

also now the times have moved on and it is no longer peaceful time of for 1990 to 2014 ,in which many countries got western investment and technical know how for industrization . Niw world have become even more hostile ,is it still okay to allow western infiltration in every sphere of India for supposedly economic benifit rather india should curtail it even that mean short term economic consequences.
 
Last edited:
Comet said:

View: https://x.com/HindenburgRes/status/1822061498845266212?t=FgoS59Wr4WI96a-Mevkumw&s=19
Click to expand...


Well, I wish it is Byjus but it can't be since they short the stock of the company they are exposing. Byjus is not listed on the stock market. It's most likely against Ambani. But I doubt they will be able to move a needle against him since Ambani's conglomerate of companies have a net profit of 1 Lakh crore. This leaves us with IT servicing companies or TATA. Let's hope whatever Hindenburg puts out it is taken with a pinch of salt. They have an agenda and they openly claim about shorting the stock of the company they are exposing.
 
Suga said:
You are right,it should be sc st themself who should protest against people who already have their father,grandfather,mother etc sarkari job from reservation getting reservation benifits,
This mentality of Sarkar maibaap is reason “dhindus” are so pathetic and sitting duck.

@ezasa and other knowledgeable members
What would happen if GOI ban all aliens own communication channels ,media, as well as SM including google. What would be consquence from burger land.

also now the times have moved on and it is no longer peaceful time of for 1990 to 2014 ,in which many countries got western investment and technical know how for industrization . Niw world have become even more hostile ,is it still okay to allow western infiltration in every sphere of India for supposedly economic benifit rather india should curtail it even that mean short term economic consequences.
Click to expand...
Actually if we are to finally phase out reservations we will have to move out affluent ones from the fold. The general tribe needs to grow further and further to make it politically possible.
 
Nutcracker said:
Let bottom 90% of SCSTs protest against the status quo if they want creamy layer. Why should BJP burn it's hands. Let it simmer and stay a discussion point till 2027 or 2029.
Click to expand...
Yes, the lower ones should protest if they have issues with the current setup.

However, since the BJP has stated that they do not intend to amend the rule, this could position them against the BJP. The issue is that these castes are among the lowest within the SC/ST categories and are often reluctant and even afraid to voice against dominant groups like the Jatavs or Meenas.

But fact is GOI itself has no intention of changing the law. It's not that they want to change it but are refraining due to potential protests.

Their intentions are clear; if they had wanted to address the issue, they would have made "settlements" with DYC and delivered a judgment similar to the Indra Sawhney case, which introduced the creamy layer concept and eliminated reservation in promotions for OBCs.
 
altruistRor said:
Yes, the lower ones should protest if they have issues with the current setup.

However, since the BJP has stated that they do not intend to amend the rule, this could position them against the BJP. The issue is that these castes are among the lowest within the SC/ST categories and are often reluctant and even afraid to voice against dominant groups like the Jatavs or Meenas.

But fact is GOI itself has no intention of changing the law. It's not that they want to change it but are refraining due to potential protests.

Their intentions are clear; if they had wanted to address the issue, they would have made "settlements" with DYC and delivered a judgment similar to the Indra Sawhney case, which introduced the creamy layer concept and eliminated reservation in promotions for OBCs.
Click to expand...
If someone believes that achieving consensus with the judiciary is impossible, they likely misunderstand how things work.

Govt often uses judiciary to deliver controversial judgments that might be difficult to pass through legislation or executive orders due to protests or negative public perception. This is evident in judgments like those related to LGBTQ rights.

For instance, US may have specific expectations from India in exchange for services provided by Indian companies in US. When the Indian government cannot fulfill these demands through legislation or executive actions, they may turn to the judiciary to ease the process.

This approach is an unwritten rule followed by governments regardless of their party affiliation.
 

Government Should Have Brought Bill To Nullify Supreme Court's 'Creamy Layer' Observation: Mallikarjun Kharge​

On Friday, the Union Cabinet also held a detailed discussion on the Supreme Court judgment on the sub-categorisation of reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes as granted in the Constitution.​


www.ndtv.com

Government Should Have Brought Bill To Nullify Supreme Court's 'Creamy Layer' Observation: Mallikarjun Kharge

Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge on Saturday said the government should have brought legislation in Parliament to nullify the part of the recent Supreme Court judgment that speaks about the 'creamy layer' among SCs and STs.
www.ndtv.com www.ndtv.com
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Miss Firing
Tracking Stolen Indian Artifacts, Antiquities & Their Recovery/Return
Replies
0
Views
21
Miss Firing
Miss Firing
Unknowncommando
Indian Navy VBSS
Replies
2
Views
114
KAB7777
KAB7777
Unknowncommando
Indian Air Force Helicopters
Replies
4
Views
82
Unknowncommando
Unknowncommando
haldilal
Indian Main Stream Media
Replies
0
Views
60
haldilal
haldilal
Azaad
Indian Defence Podcasts : No Discussions
Replies
0
Views
110
Azaad
Azaad

Latest Replies

Featured Content

Trending Threads

Share this Site

Donate via Bitcoin - bc1qpc3h2l430vlfflc8w02t7qlkvltagt2y4k9dc2

qrcode
Back
Top