LCA TEJAS MK-I & MK-IA: News and Discussion (21 Viewers)

[redpanda]

View: https://x.com/DefSysCI/status/1932457409815150603

Seems like HAL wants it for less than 2k crores.

 

[Indx TechStyle]

yes...but STAR nd brahmos hv similar liquid fuelled ramjet engine...so we can develop a super cruise missile like brahmos from STAR target testing platform in future. we r not hearing anything about brahmos NG development. so i was saying may be they want our own mini brahmos later from STAR missiles.
i dont think brahmos NG alternative lie in project ITCM nd vishnu. coz brahmos NG is supercruise missile is based on ramjet engine. meanwhile subsonic missile ITCM is based on turbofan engine nd hypersonic vishnu missile will be based on screamjet engine.

1. STAR is developed as a product of existing technologies India has for interception exercise. Star is not a precursor for BrahMos in any circumstances (unless you wish to see a BrahMos variant getting intercepted by CIWS). STAR is a confirmation that we have technology and not a TD of BrahMos.
2. In terms of role, ITCM and Project Vishnu fulfill the requirement. BrahMos-NG being produced though is a good to have thing as other great powers too produce multiple kind of weapons for same role to keep options open, BrahMos and STAR are not and not required to related.

 

[mist_consecutive]

I am dropping by in this thread to listen to desi phanboys tipping their fedora hats and going

"acctually.... IAF is responsible for Tejas delay, don't blame PSUs, also laal salaam comrades !"

 

[redpanda]

I am dropping by in this thread to listen to desi phanboys tipping their fedora hats and going

"acctually.... IAF is responsible for Tejas delay, don't blame PSUs, also laal salaam comrades !"

Actually phanboys are blaming AMPL now instead of HAL lmao. Not here but on X. Blaming GoI for unnecessarily pushing private players when well established PSUs like BEL was there. PSU phanboys are doing everything to save face of HAL who is probably the one behind delay of certification of SVK to begin with.

 

[Tumba]

IAF chief was right about these loonies, they should import hundreds of more Rafales instead of wasting time on these babus.

View: https://x.com/alpha_defense/status/1939010590732886318

Happens when DRDO and HAL both dont hire based on merit
Fuckin clowns

 

[redpanda]

Happens when DRDO and HAL both dont hire based on merit
Fuckin clowns

Isme merit kaha se aya sir. It's just corruption through and through. DRDO has done its job and even suggesting practical solution. It's HAL being Dalal again.

"DRDO officials point out a viable alternative—integrating the Uttam radar with imported EW systems until the SRK suite receives complete certification. In fact, making HAL’s decision even more perplexing, in a recent internal communication to HAL and DRDO in April, CEMILAC stated that the Uttam radar had completed four phases of flight trials. Additionally, the radar hardware had undergone qualification tests according to the LCA Mk1A’s requirements. To facilitate the induction of the radar, CEMILAC recommended commencing production of the radar subsystems, with HAL’s avionics division in Hyderabad serving as the lead system integrator."

Uttam + Israeli EW is possible but HAL don't wanna accept that solution..

 

[ArjunMK1A]

Any subsystem we are importing dozens of MSME were loosing projects/revenue etc.

Also LRTR radar is in service for 3 years. But still MFSTAR is preferred owing to Barak 8

 

[Tumba]

Isme merit kaha se aya sir. It's just corruption through and through. DRDO has done its job and even suggesting practical solution. It's HAL being Dalal again.

"DRDO officials point out a viable alternative—integrating the Uttam radar with imported EW systems until the SRK suite receives complete certification. In fact, making HAL’s decision even more perplexing, in a recent internal communication to HAL and DRDO in April, CEMILAC stated that the Uttam radar had completed four phases of flight trials. Additionally, the radar hardware had undergone qualification tests according to the LCA Mk1A’s requirements. To facilitate the induction of the radar, CEMILAC recommended commencing production of the radar subsystems, with HAL’s avionics division in Hyderabad serving as the lead system integrator."

Uttam + Israeli EW is possible but HAL don't wanna accept that solution..

This is completely a show run by incompetent fools both in HAL and DRDO and no way a merit based institution like IAF will take any product on the go either one provide full fledged solution this jugaad doesnt work in situations when Tejas will be flying again enemies.

This basically means incompetent fools both in DRDO, HAL and certification authorities never planned and even if planned were unsuccessful for achieving the certification hence by the pressure of IAF… HAL just doing what they do best screwing few nuts n bots fckin incompetent clowns and people expect then to deliver AMCA..

We can only rely on merit based mega corps to deliver some good results not some Non merit PSUs or start up run by children of filth like Chandigarh lobby…

Sell both DRDO and HAL to Adani, Ambani, LnT otherwise we will see AMCA getting stretched till kingdom come

 

[bakofbakchod]

Might be a good idea to hand out capital punishment to the entire top brass of HAL and IAF, since both sides love blaming the other.... meanwhile the panda to the north is inducting 150+ jets each year

 

[ArjunMK1A]

This is completely a show run by incompetent fools both in HAL and DRDO and no way a merit based institution like IAF will take any product on the go either one provide full fledged solution this jugaad doesnt work in situations when Tejas will be flying again enemies.

This basically means incompetent fools both in DRDO, HAL and certification authorities never planned and even if planned were unsuccessful for achieving the certification hence by the pressure of IAF… HAL just doing what they do best screwing few nuts n bots fckin incompetent clowns and people expect then to deliver AMCA..

We can only rely on merit based mega corps to deliver some good results not some Non merit PSUs or start up run by children of filth like Chandigarh lobby…

Sell both DRDO and HAL to Adani, Ambani, LnT otherwise we will see AMCA getting stretched till kingdom come

Saar DRDO is an R&D Agency. How can we sell R&D agency to Adani, Ambani,L&T who spent less money than number of words in R&D. They will start to do german engineering at affordable price jhoomla.


Defence Minister should conduct Quarterly review with an Bamboo Lathi so whenever deadlines missed he should spank them. The only person who done is Late Sir Manohar Parrikar. He called out the RFI from our Armed forces stating them as Star wars weapons.

 

[vin pahadi (kumauni)]

Happens when DRDO and HAL both dont hire based on merit
Fuckin clowns

bro first thing most people agree our education system based in memorization. so getting more marks doesnt mean that person hv merit to invent something.
second thing, all entrance test r medium to choose candidates. they r not proofing that students who r getting more number r more talented. Getting more number isnt a "true merit". coz if a person getting 1st rank in a entrance test, it doesn't mean he will sustain that position in new exams also. i mean it can be possible that top ranker get 50 rank or 100 rank or 500 or 1000 rank in next exam. entrance exams r just to choose candidates from lot of students. it isnt their capability test or superiority over other candidates. a capable candidate can perform bad for different reason (anxiety etc) in a exam.
For example we know apj abdul kalam hv good contribution in DRDO nd ISRO. It doesnt mean he was 1 rank holder in DRDO entrance test. although by merit logic, he should be 1st rank holder.

 

[angryindian]

Might be a good idea to hand out capital punishment to the entire top brass of HAL and IAF, since both sides love blaming the other.... meanwhile the panda to the north is inducting 150+ jets each year

Let alone China,the fact that a 10 times economically smaller and barely functional country like Pakistan has not only managed to achieve military parity but is also on the verge of overtaking us technologically.

This is beyond embarrassing; had it been the US or China, a lot of people would have been facing the gallows for allowing this to happen.

 

[redpanda]

Tbh this doesn't really affect Tejas Mk1A production. At this point I would be happy if it flies in a decent number in next 2 years.

 

[Vilander]

Let alone China,the fact that a 10 times economically smaller and barely functional country like Pakistan has not only managed to achieve military parity but is also on the verge of overtaking us technologically.

This is beyond embarrassing; had it been the US or China, a lot of people would have been facing the gallows for allowing this to happen.

So much delay in 4 th gen dev. So much delay in procurement, such heavy cost over run. So far away from 5th gen dev. It's embarrassing and also painful to see this. Horrible.

 

[redpanda]

Mk1A isn't further delayed though. Why is everyone reacting like that? HAL probably picked Israeli system to avoid further delays because they are under the fire from IAF. Also the previous delays were because of GE supply chain issue.

 

[liberalredditor]

As i have said before too, hal babooz deserve belt treatment, they sold their loyalty to mossadfuckers. Drdo has everything, but how will psu sarkari baboons earn their hard earned roti kapda makaan. At this point i support iaf to buy 200 rafale 200 su57 and 200 f35. Just sell of this nation and import everything

 

[redpanda]

As i have said before too, hal babooz deserve belt treatment, they sold their loyalty to mossadfuckers. Drdo has everything, but how will psu sarkari baboons earn their hard earned roti kapda makaan. At this point i support iaf to buy 200 rafale 200 su57 and 200 f35. Just sell of this nation and import everything

I'm just hoping them to deliver all those Mk1A with even that Israeli suite. I mean that Israeli radar and ew suite is pretty good. Better than nothing at the end. And hope IAF orders additional 97 Mk1A because, by then HAL would have no choice to use Uttam + SRK on those. Because I expect DRDO to not give up on certifying their stuff.

 

[shade2]

So i was saying about HAL impoorting some part from abroad when DRDO item was available

The part was "Primary Actuators" imported from Moog inc. of US

LCA Tejas updates: Integration testing of India-made actuators begins

HAL's Bengaluru facility begins integration testing of indigenous actuators for LCA Tejas, aiming for self-reliance. Vikram Sarabhai Space Centre supports indigenisation, with plans to replace costly imported actuators with efficient domestic versions

www.theweek.in

Below some Atmanirbhar devotee twitter patrakar has exposed HAL's love for imported parts


View: https://x.com/writetake/status/1860486646598144481

Or maybe HAL only doing it for customers?
Idk

 

[Tumba]

bro first thing most people agree our education system based in memorization. so getting more marks doesnt mean that person hv merit to invent something.
second thing, all entrance test r medium to choose candidates. they r not proofing that students who r getting more number r more talented. Getting more number isnt a "true merit". coz if a person getting 1st rank in a entrance test, it doesn't mean he will sustain that position in new exams also. i mean it can be possible that top ranker get 50 rank or 100 rank or 500 or 1000 rank in next exam. entrance exams r just to choose candidates from lot of students. it isnt their capability test or superiority over other candidates. a capable candidate can perform bad for different reason (anxiety etc) in a exam.
For example we know apj abdul kalam hv good contribution in DRDO nd ISRO. It doesnt mean he was 1 rank holder in DRDO entrance test. although by merit logic, he should be 1st rank holder.

U r just too naive … IIT and DRDO has people working which didnt even pass the test

 

[shade2]

I'm just hoping them to deliver all those Mk1A with even that Israeli suite. I mean that Israeli radar and ew suite is pretty good. Better than nothing at the end. And hope IAF orders additional 97 Mk1A because, by then HAL would have no choice to use Uttam + SRK on those. Because I expect DRDO to not give up on certifying their stuff.

There is no need to use Uttam then, it will forever be a "science project" item and even Atmanirbhar Armenia can't help us there.