Sinking State of Bangladesh: Idiotic Musings

[Hari Sud]

Bangladesh is not aiming to have a direct military bellicose with India. What they are aiming to is to start an insurrection in Muslim-majority districts in West Bengal, especially Murshidabad,Malda, and Uttar Dinajpur which are close to the Siliguri corridor.Further it aims to start a separatist insurgency in Lower Assam.They already had Muslim United Liberation Tigers of Assam but it didn't work out and faded under the shadow of ULFA.

That will be a great disadvantage to Bangladesh because India can expel 10 million Bangladeshis from Assam and West Bengal. In addition Hindu population group which is splintered in West Bengal will become one.

 

[vin pahadi (kumauni)]

Also, 50% population of Pak too.

Logistically and geographically, it's impossible for US and Chian to help BD in case of an Indo BD conflict. Nowhere, by land or sea or air.

Even if a help is sent, it's simply insane to hit Indian military in Bay of Bengal near India's East Coast and Indian military in Myanmar and it's own territory. There is a reason why India with even shit equipment could take over BD in 13 days during 1971 war.

BD's geograhic, military and economic disadvantage against India worse worse than condition of small post Soviet states against Russia. Preventing an Indian expedition of BD requires an expedition of India itself which is not practical for any country.

For vs BD part, Indian Armed forces will decimate their main command in days if not hours within starting of war. Problem will be guerilla warfare from local population (unless GoI chooses to do massacres which they won't).

its absurd to even think about that america nd china will support bangladesh directly....when pakistan was allies with america nd china, they didnt directly help pakistan in war atleast in 3 wars (except america nd british intervention in arab sea in 1971). even war time we not heard that USA nd china provide arms etc to pakistan... meanwhile bangladesh hv nothing to provide america nd china, except military or naval base. which can be happen in future. atleast pakistan hv/had geopolitical advantage, unlike bangladesh. dont know why stupid Bangladeshi count china factor in potential india nd bangladesh war. china can help bangladesh to provide weapons, but that option they can get from other countries also (like turkey, pakistan etc).

 

[vin pahadi (kumauni)]

Bangladesh is not aiming to have a direct military bellicose with India. What they are aiming to is to start an insurrection in Muslim-majority districts in West Bengal, especially Murshidabad,Malda, and Uttar Dinajpur which are close to the Siliguri corridor.Further it aims to start a separatist insurgency in Lower Assam.They already had Muslim United Liberation Tigers of Assam but it didn't work out and faded under the shadow of ULFA.

even if they will successful, that will create us Naxal like situation in different areas. now naxal is very limited, our police force nd reserve force is enough to handle these muslim organisation. we didnt deployed our army for naxal solution. only problem i see which is headache for us, is population demographic shift. where first middle east cult is breeding much faster nd second dessert cult is converting very fastly. if we control nd reverse this situation, other problems r not that big to handle.
ideally i think india should hv population near 250 million - 500 million max for its size nd resources. so we can easily handle many civil wars nd genocide. not saying it should happen, but even this worst case scenario isnt problematic for india. demographic change is biggest problem for india, in my opinion. other problems can be handled. demographic majority of hindus is biggest reason, we survive all those past invasions.

 

[Indx TechStyle]

Bangladesh is not aiming to have a direct military bellicose with India. What they are aiming to is to start an insurrection in Muslim-majority districts in West Bengal, especially Murshidabad,Malda, and Uttar Dinajpur which are close to the Siliguri corridor.Further it aims to start a separatist insurgency in Lower Assam.They already had Muslim United Liberation Tigers of Assam but it didn't work out and faded under the shadow of ULFA.

I was discussing a direct military conflict so your post is irrelevant.

Regards

India can expel 10 million Bangladeshis from Assam and West Bengal.

No, we can't.

 

[Hari Sud]

I was discussing a direct military conflict so your post is irrelevant.

Regards

No, we can't.

You are imagination is running wild for a direct Bangladesh military conflict with India

 

[Indx TechStyle]

You are imagination is running wild for a direct Bangladesh military conflict with India

I didn't, someone else did and I dismissed. Indeed reading a bit of post helps in responding better than for sake of responding.

BTW, Finding and transferring 1 cr Bdeshis across the border somehow sounds not hallucination to you. Isn't it?

 

[FalconSlayers]

But as per kanglus Indians alone were remitting $10 billion out of their Kanglupore?

Foreigners in Bangladesh remitted $130.6m in first 10 months of FY24

Says finance minister

www.thedailystar.net

 

[angryindian]

That will be a great disadvantage to Bangladesh because India can expel 10 million Bangladeshis from Assam and West Bengal. In addition Hindu population group which is splintered in West Bengal will become one.

No, we can't do anything like that because the people living there are citizens of India, and doing so will lead to a massive humanitarian crisis and an embargo on India.

I blame the entire political leadership since independence for this crisis. Babasaheb Ambedkar and
Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel had this foresight and understanding that "demographics is destiny" but the rest lived in an imaginative world of their own. They even resettled Bangladeshis across the country which caused a lot of social, and ethnic disturbances and even demographic change in Tripura.

 

[Azaad]

They even resettled Bangladeshis across the country which caused a lot of social, and ethnic disturbances and even demographic change in Tripura.

GoI settled Bangladeshis across the country ? Those were Bengali Hindus who were thus settled including in Tripura.

 

[angryindian]

GoI settled Bangladeshis across the country ? Those were Bengali Hindus who were thus settled including in Tripura.

Mostly Hindus but a significant number of Muslims as well. However, unlike the rest of us,people in the North East don't just look only from the angle of religion but ethnicity too. Large-scale migration to Tripura resulted in local Tripuris becoming a minority in their own state and this caused massive resentment and hence an insurgency.

 

[Azaad]

Mostly Hindus but a significant number of Muslims as well. However, unlike the rest of us,people in the North East don't just look only from the angle of religion but ethnicity too. Large-scale migration to Tripura resulted in local Tripuris becoming a minority in their own state and this caused massive resentment and hence an insurgency. Migration from Bangladesh is also the root cause of insurgency in Assam.

I've yet to come across GoI "officially" settling Bangladeshi Muslims anywhere in India
I hope you're not mistaking CPM earlier & TMC cadres now "settling" Bengali Muslims by helping them get Indian documents followed by citizenship as the GoI or official policy to settle these illegal immigrants.

 

[Nutcracker]

But as per kanglus Indians alone were remitting $10 billion out of their Kanglupore?

Foreigners in Bangladesh remitted $130.6m in first 10 months of FY24

Says finance minister

www.thedailystar.net

Commie Bhodrocuck whorsons and their delusion.


View: https://x.com/OpinionatedBong/status/1181878621062873090

 

[ezsasa]

Commie Bhodrocuck whorsons and their delusion.


View: https://x.com/OpinionatedBong/status/1181878621062873090

this has been going on for some time.

this news article is from 2018, when shringla was ambassador there, and he has denied it on record.

https://www.daily-sun.com/printversion/details/335760

but would be fun to find out how exactly this started, earliest i found was from 2015 in def.pk .

 

[Nutcracker]

Commie Bhodrocuck whorsons and their delusion.


View: https://x.com/OpinionatedBong/status/1181878621062873090

there are not even 20 thousand Indians by 2024 in BhosdDesh . How can 10 Lakh work back in 2017.

"External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar on Tuesday said that there are around 19,000 Indians in Bangladesh. Of these, 9,000 are students – most of whom returned to India in July. “We are in close and continuous touch with the Indian community in Bangladesh through our diplomatic missions."

Bangladesh crisis: How many Indians are in the neighbouring nation? Are they safe?

India brought back 190 non-essential staff and their families a special Air India (AI1128) flight. Another 20 to 30 senior staff remain at the Dhaka High Commission. External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar has said that there are around 19,000 Indians in Bangladesh and that New Delhi expects...

www.firstpost.com

 

[ezsasa]

this has been going on for some time.

this news article is from 2018, when shringla was ambassador there, and he has denied it on record.

https://www.daily-sun.com/printversion/details/335760

but would be fun to find out how exactly this started, earliest i found was from 2015 in def.pk .

some study from 2013 citing hawala, quoted in 2015.
number was 3.716 billion in 2013, by 2018 it has become 10 billion, by progression we should be hearing about 20 billion for 2024 cited by SM posts in 2030.

===​

where ever that info came from, "the centre for policy dialogue" NGO wallahs legitimised that piece of data by quoting it and making it official.​

====

CPD study on remittance outflow cited​

It is reported that Bangladesh stands 5th among the 15 nations sending remittances to India after UAE, USA, Saudi Arabia and UK. In 2013, remittance from Bangladesh to India was about $ 3.716 billion. Is it not amazing? However, that is the official figure. According to other sources, an almost equal amount, if not more, is sent through hundi and other illegal methods.

CPD study on remittance outflow cited | CPD

CPD study on remittance outflow cited in an Op-Ed published in The Daily Star on Thursday, 8 January 2015.

cpd.org.bd

 

[Miss Firing]

Commie Bhodrocuck whorsons and their delusion.


View: https://x.com/OpinionatedBong/status/1181878621062873090

This commie chudrocuck whoreson has shown genocidal level hatred against Hindus in some other tweets. Had seen some one posted it on DFI.

He is always seen kanging for the Britshits, maybe someone should send his old hate tweets to the Britshit police. Lets see if they live up-to their claim of "fighting hate".

BTW, there was a certain Chudrolock commie in Oxford who stated that Sanatanis have no place there i.e. in Oxford. He is still there on the job i believe.

 

[ezsasa]

some study from 2013 citing hawala, quoted in 2015.
number was 3.716 billion in 2013, by 2018 it has become 10 billion, by progression we should be hearing about 20 billion for 2024 cited by SM posts in 2030.

===​

where ever that info came from, "the centre for policy dialogue" NGO wallahs legitimised that piece of data by quoting it and making it official.​

====

CPD study on remittance outflow cited​

CPD study on remittance outflow cited | CPD

CPD study on remittance outflow cited in an Op-Ed published in The Daily Star on Thursday, 8 January 2015.

cpd.org.bd

so there was academic rebuttal from IDSA as well in 2014. beedi's source is silicon India magazine.

Some Bangladeshi authors18 now argue that there are 500,000 Indians who are staying illegally in Bangladesh and sending USD 3,716 million quoting Silicon India magazine asif it is some primary source of information.19 One of the authors also cites the source of his information to a survey20 without giving the details of where these surveys were published and who did the survey. Even the article of Silicon India21 that various Bangladeshi authorshave generously quoted which includes recent editorial in the New Age22 does not sayhow they arrived at this figure and the source of their data.23

https://www.idsa.in/system/files/sspattanaik160514_0.pdf

silicon India magazine itself was outed as a fraud by newslaundry no less in 2016.

https://www.newslaundry.com/2016/07...-to-become-a-top-25-legal-consultant-in-india

there is some reference to some world bank report, that WB report itself is missing now.

it's a citation loop, no point looking into this further.

 

[Cheepek]

2,010 communal attacks in Bangladesh since August 4 to 20: Oikyo Parishad

Among them, 157 families had their homes attacked, looted, vandalised, and set on fire

www.thedailystar.net

 

[Cheepek]

A class 10th Hindu girl is kidnapped 2 weeks after pamplets threatening her abduction & conversion were pasted near her house

Schoolgirl abducted after threats in Kurigram

A student of class 10 was abducted in Kurigram's Phulbari upazila yesterday evening, just over two weeks after posters saying that the "girl of the family" would be taken and converted to Islam were found pinned to trees near her home.

www.thedailystar.net

 

[Azaad]

so there was academic rebuttal from IDSA as well in 2014. beedi's source is silicon India magazine.



https://www.idsa.in/system/files/sspattanaik160514_0.pdf

silicon India magazine itself was outed as a fraud by newslaundry no less in 2016.

https://www.newslaundry.com/2016/07...-to-become-a-top-25-legal-consultant-in-india

there is some reference to some world bank report, that WB report itself is missing now.

it's a citation loop, no point looking into this further.

There's another angle to this - since 25% of the RMG sector is controlled by Indians there's always the issue of remittance of undeclared profits or the usual over invoicing / under invoicing aspect especially considering the local market deals in cash & a certain amount of exports to India could also be in cash.

In addition to this phenomenon there'd be influential Bangladeshis send money across to be invested in India or for safe keeping . Finally there's also a element of terrorist funding as well as narcotics.